Elinor Ostrom Would Like a Word With Your Moderation Policy
What a Nobel economist who studied cow pastures can teach us about governing a forum
Ask any community manager about governance in their community, and we’ll point you right to the code of conduct, guidelines, or some variation of these documents. Either look at enough communities and work on enough communities, and you begin to notice it’s basically all the same thing.
Somewhere along the way, somebody handed us a code of conduct template, we swapped in our company name, added a line about being kind, and hit publish on launch day. Then we built an escalation ladder: warning, timeout, ban. Staff decides. Done.
And I for one, hadn’t put too much thought into it all. We’ve all kind of agreed those governance documents exist to provide boundaries and structure. The average community member will hardly look at them ever.
But it turns out that model has a lineage, even if we never think about it.
Ready for a history lesson?
In 1833, a British mathematician named William Forster Lloyd sketched out a rather simple concept. While adding an extra cow to a herd seems like a great concept to each individual herder, the addition of all those extra cows leads to overgrazing. Overgrazing impacts everyone negatively and outweighs the benefit of the additional cow.
Then in 1968, an ecologist named Garrett Hardin (who evidently was not the most upstanding guy) wrote “The Tragedy of the Commons” borrowing William’s scenario arguing that any shared resource gets trashed by self-interest unless you either privatize it or hand it to a strong central authority.
I don’t know about you, but that last line there makes me squirmy. Gives me the ick, but reality is that it’s how we run community platforms. Admins up top, rules flowing down, members on the receiving end.
And it… “works”. But what if there was a better way?
Then in 1990, a gal named Elinor Ostrom - with evidently more optimism than Garrett - published Governing the Commons. She spent decades upon decades doing something kind of uncommon for an economist: she studied commons that hadn’t collapsed. Swiss alpine meadows. Japanese village forests. Irrigation canals in Spain. Some had been shared and well-governed for centuries without anybody privatizing anything or appointing a king.

In 2009 she won the Nobel (you go girl!) for explaining how - and she boiled what the healthy ones had in common down to eight design principles.
And needless to say, I did not expect a newsletter about forums to end up in agricultural economics either. And yet, here we are.
For sh*ts and giggles, I decided to run my own codes of conduct and playbooks against her list this past week. And y’all… I can do better. We can do better.
I won’t go into all eight principles as we’d need something nearly as long as Elinor’s entire dissertation (giant PDF here). But I do want to explore the first one.
The first principle is clearly defined boundaries: who’s in, who’s out, who gets to use the resource. And this is awkward, because I have spent a truly unreasonable number of words rambling about login walls and trust levels. So either Ostrom is wrong about forums, or I am.
Or maybe we’re both right to an extent? A pasture can be overgrazed. A forum thread can’t. A thousand lurkers can read the same solved post and it’s still sitting there, fully intact, for lurker number one thousand and one. Economists call that non-rival. Reading doesn’t deplete anything.
What does get depleted is the person writing the answer. Every repeat question, every low-effort post, every snippy reply to a volunteer draws down the same well. That well is finite, and when it runs dry your community looks exactly as active as it did yesterday, right up until it doesn’t.
The commons in your community is the patience of the people who answer, and every rule you write should be protecting it.
So the boundaries go around that. Leave the front door open. Let anyone read, let anyone ask. Draw the lines around who shapes the rules, who moderates, who holds the keys. That’s where membership should mean something. Turns out Ostrom and I agree; I’d just been fencing the wrong field for the wrong goats. Oops.
Once you see the commons that way, a few of her other principles start rearranging how I think about the work.
Start with sanctions. Ostrom found that healthy commons begin their punishments almost embarrassingly small, usually a word from a neighbor. Most of our escalation ladders skip that rung entirely and open with an official warning from staff, which to a newcomer reads like a letter from the IRS. The first consequence in a community should come from a peer and feel like a raised eyebrow. Save the formal machinery for people who’ve ignored three eyebrows.
Then there’s who writes the rules. In 1517 the villagers of Törbel, Switzerland agreed that nobody could send more cows up to the summer pasture than they could feed through the winter. No outside authority imposed that. It fit the place because the people who knew the place wrote it. Your top contributors know your place better than your legal team does. Hand them the pen at the next guidelines revision. People enforce rules they wrote. They route around rules they were handed.
Monitoring matters too and Ostrom was specific: the monitors were usually users themselves or directly accountable to them. Staff-only moderation is the absentee landlord version of governance. Member moderators help, and so does making staff moderation visible, with names and faces, so members know who’s watching and can push back on them.
And finally, conflict resolution has to be cheap and fast. Which brings me to my favorite thing I learned this past week: The Tribunal de las Aguas in Valencia has settled irrigation disputes for something like a thousand years. It’s Europe’s oldest active legal institution.
Every Thursday at noon, farmers show up outside the cathedral and make their case out loud. Elected representatives from each canal rule on the spot. No paperwork, no lawyers, no appeals process that takes a fiscal quarter (which sounds lovely right about now). Most community fights don’t need a verdict. They need someone visibly hearing them out, quickly, in front of everyone.
I’m still scheming on what our version of the Thursday court looks like. A standing weekly thread? An open office hour where anyone can contest a mod call? I don’t know yet. But I keep picturing those farmers out in the noon sun, arguing over stolen water while tourists take photos. And I’m jealous since it’s likely not one person in that square has ever asked whether the canal is driving engagement.

Discussion about this post